Edward
Bartender
- Messages
- 26,337
- Location
- London, UK
The 70s version I've not seen, though I plan to seek it out once I've read the novel. Should be interesting for comparison, though when it comes to books I've become a fan of the "limited series" approach that allows for greater engagement with more of the plot of a dense book.
Last few evenings I've been watching House of David on Prime. Nice production. Tells the story of David of the Tribe of Judah, from his beginnings to the end of Goliath (that's not seriously a spoiler, is it?) in the first series, while the second series promises to take him to the end of Saul. The showrunners are apparently keen to do a third season taking David towards the end of his life- we'll see if that's so popular. It's a nicely done production ,which clearly has had serious money pumped into it. A modern take on the Bible-adjacent swords and sandals genre, - this summons up similar notes to me as Ben Hur, The Robe, The Ten Commandments... Casting is very good: the players in this all look like they all belong in that time and place; this is no John Wayne as Ghengis Khan horror.
It's not a show for anyone who is looking for a strict depiction of the Biblical rendering of the story exclusively. There's definitely a lot of fleshing out the relationships and characters portrayed, though nothing that contradicts the Biblical version either. The depiction of Goliath as a Nephilim works rather well; he's had siblings appear so far in the plot in a way that holds consistent with the story as well. We'll see how season two develops. The depiction of the Prophet Samuel is a joy, particularly his sense of humour. Echoes of Gandalf, which doubtless helps sell to a contemporary audience, and with Tolkien's ouevre being largely a Biblical allegory anyhow.... (Granted, his Gandalf is Christ rather than Samuel, but the tone of human connection to the Divine is the same). Friends who follow the Jewish faith have said it represents the pre-Christian Jewish rituals very well.
I shouldn't think one would need to be a believer in order to be entertained by this, any more so than with Lord of the Rings or The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, though for those of us who do connect with that worldview, it works nicely.
If this genre appeals, it's worth seeking out.
Last few evenings I've been watching House of David on Prime. Nice production. Tells the story of David of the Tribe of Judah, from his beginnings to the end of Goliath (that's not seriously a spoiler, is it?) in the first series, while the second series promises to take him to the end of Saul. The showrunners are apparently keen to do a third season taking David towards the end of his life- we'll see if that's so popular. It's a nicely done production ,which clearly has had serious money pumped into it. A modern take on the Bible-adjacent swords and sandals genre, - this summons up similar notes to me as Ben Hur, The Robe, The Ten Commandments... Casting is very good: the players in this all look like they all belong in that time and place; this is no John Wayne as Ghengis Khan horror.
It's not a show for anyone who is looking for a strict depiction of the Biblical rendering of the story exclusively. There's definitely a lot of fleshing out the relationships and characters portrayed, though nothing that contradicts the Biblical version either. The depiction of Goliath as a Nephilim works rather well; he's had siblings appear so far in the plot in a way that holds consistent with the story as well. We'll see how season two develops. The depiction of the Prophet Samuel is a joy, particularly his sense of humour. Echoes of Gandalf, which doubtless helps sell to a contemporary audience, and with Tolkien's ouevre being largely a Biblical allegory anyhow.... (Granted, his Gandalf is Christ rather than Samuel, but the tone of human connection to the Divine is the same). Friends who follow the Jewish faith have said it represents the pre-Christian Jewish rituals very well.
I shouldn't think one would need to be a believer in order to be entertained by this, any more so than with Lord of the Rings or The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, though for those of us who do connect with that worldview, it works nicely.
If this genre appeals, it's worth seeking out.


